Kerry v Cork

or maybe a scrum?

mullins wrote:

Shinners wrote:Point taken TC I can only go on highlights so I cannot comment on Sunday but he was at it in the drawn game aswell which I watched. A good player who is not as potent as he used to be.

Well Moss, what words of wisdom had O'Sé? He who got very ill tempered in his later years and had more than his share of incidents with Cork players.

Don't get caught wait till there is a scum before gouging...

"Mullins slams Kerry Scum!"

RMDrive wrote:

mullins wrote:

Shinners wrote:Point taken TC I can only go on highlights so I cannot comment on Sunday but he was at it in the drawn game aswell which I watched. A good player who is not as potent as he used to be.

Well Moss, what words of wisdom had O'Sé? He who got very ill tempered in his later years and had more than his share of incidents with Cork players.

Don't get caught wait till there is a scum before gouging...

"Mullins slams Kerry Scum!"

Never Rmd Never there our closest rival

Shinners wrote:or maybe a scrum?

thats what i said shinners

[quote="bocerty"][quote="3inarow08"]

Real Kerry Fan wrote:




bias my **** you should be on stage Triona - i call it as i see it - Gooch was doing a fair bit of 'diving' from what i seen of the game, it didnt take much to put him down, when Cavanagh was at the same craic a few years ago he was getting castigated by everyone, and Tom O' Sullivan was doing his share of fouling along with Griffin but you Kerry lads chose to ignore that and instead point out that Canty deserved red for the clash with Galvin - now thats bias. You are a more cynical side than you care to admit and yet we all get labelled with the puke football label when the truth is you guys are masters at it - Billy Morgan was right.

Had a certain Tyrone player done what Galvin done then i would guarantee it would have caused more controversy - had it even happened in an Ulster championship many of you would have had a field day but when its one of your own you are more selective in your criticism, thats bias Triona not the sh!te you accuse me off. I will have no problem criticising a Tyrone player if i feel they warrant it pity you cant do the same.

Look boc I have never attacked a county,club, player or fans but having read your post I note that you must have some almighty chip on both shoulders because I have never seen such vitriol against a county ,its players and supporters. I mentioned the Canty incident as an example of all serious incidents should be highlighted on the Sunday Game or none. I will not even bother to reply to rest of your rant.

[quote="bocerty"][quote="3inarow08"]

Real Kerry Fan wrote:

to see the incidents with one eye.

Is that a Kerry saying I've never heard before DoS used the exact same expression on the radio earlier on

[quote="mossbags"][quote="bocerty"]

3inarow08 wrote:

Real Kerry Fan wrote:

to see the incidents with one eye.

Is that a Kerry saying I've never heard before DoS used the exact same expression on the radio earlier on

Yes moss the blind one

[quote="Real Kerry Fan"][quote="mossbags"]

bocerty wrote:

3inarow08 wrote:

Real Kerry Fan wrote:

to see the incidents with one eye.

Is that a Kerry saying I've never heard before DoS used the exact same expression on the radio earlier on

Yes moss the blind one

Ah right, no wonder I didn't cop it, all three of my eyes are deaf

I no longer have RTE and cannot get the internet feed because I do not live in Ireland. I could drivee to a club in Belfast maybe, but.....

Galvin? Did he suddenly just decide to assault the Cork man? Is he a pschopath?

Or perhaps there has been words exchanged or other things we do not see.

By all acount he deserved red but he does not deserve all the crap the media dish out to him. The man is picked on because the opposition know he will react.

A few years ago O'Leary was trying his best to get Galvin sent off, and then had a blatant dive, complete with wink at the camera, to get Tomas O'Shea sent off. In the replay O'mahoney aped this and took a dive and was rightly crucified, but NO_ONE mentioned O'Leary who established the trend.

So I do have some sympathy for Galvin, wonderful player.

And he will be raring to go in the semi final.

bocerty wrote:

bias my **** you should be on stage Triona - i call it as i see it - Gooch was doing a fair bit of 'diving' from what i seen of the game, it didnt take much to put him down, when Cavanagh was at the same craic a few years ago he was getting castigated by everyone, and Tom O' Sullivan was doing his share of fouling along with Griffin but you Kerry lads chose to ignore that and instead point out that Canty deserved red for the clash with Galvin - now thats bias. You are a more cynical side than you care to admit and yet we all get labelled with the puke football label when the truth is you guys are masters at it - Billy Morgan was right.

Had a certain Tyrone player done what Galvin done then i would guarantee it would have caused more controversy - had it even happened in an Ulster championship many of you would have had a field day but when its one of your own you are more selective in your criticism, thats bias Triona not the sh!te you accuse me off. I will have no problem criticising a Tyrone player if i feel they warrant it pity you cant do the same.

Maybe you should look up the definition of bias. You call it as you see it ya? Ya right. You call the things you want to see and never mention the things you don't want to see. That's bias in my eyes and RKF and myself have picked up on it.

Now, as RKF with regards to himself has mentioned above - have you ever heard me after a Tyrone match giving out yards about any incident involving a Tyrone player? No is the answer to that question. (Bar any time they play Kerry, in which I will always defend my county)

I'd like to bring your attention to the above highlighted bit in your post. Can you tell me where I said that Canty deserved red for his clash with Galvin and I ignored Tom O' Sullivan's and Griffin's fouling? Have a good long look lad cos you won't find it. How can you even say that when the only posts I've made on this matter are that I didn't get to see the game live? And then I posted saying that some of the Kerry lads are up to their old usual and that they'd want to cop on. Do you not remember me admitting that? You even agreed with me and then took another swipe at us. You can't let it go, can you?

Are you trying to lump every Kerry poster on the internet together by saying "you Kerry lads"? Will I call you up on every post Dellboypolecat or PomeroyPlunkett makes because they just happen to be from Tyrone also??? You're beginning to look awful foolish now Boc!

And then you try and bring the whole siege mentality thing into it with the anti-Tyrone/anti-Ulster bias! When it happens to my own I'm more selective in my criticism - complete bull - see above, my second post. And as for me being selective, once again, show me some of my criticism of any other county/player. So trying to label me as biased will not work.

bocerty wrote:

are you suggesting he gets away with it??????

while the GAA needs Paul Galvin the 'footballer' we could do without Paul Galvin the 'person' if thats all he has to offer - but then he is 'sacred' to many on here and they choose to overlook his dark side and instead offer lame excuses like he was provoked. The CCCC will probably do the same!!!!!

Some day he will provoke the wrong guy and get his just rewards for it.

I am not suggesting he gets away with it! How did you come to that moronic deduction? If a player commits an offence he deserves to get punished. Simple as. You stated that he needed a lengthy ban as it would be the only thing to sort him out. I pointed out that he has already served a lengthy ban in his career, something which you must've forgotten, and it hasn't sorted him out, has it?! He's still getting in trouble, isn't he?!

And I love your little veiled threat at the end. I'll be sure not to warn Paul, just in case he loses any sleep over it.

Bocerty single-handedly has 2 Kerry men on the ropes here . Note the attempts to talk about anything other than the actual incident at hand. An admirable and expected defense but pretty groundless all the same.

*crouches behind Errigal to shelter from expected backlash*

RMDrive wrote:Bocerty single-handedly has 2 Kerry men on the ropes here . Note the attempts to talk about anything other than the actual incident at hand. An admirable and expected defense but pretty groundless all the same.

*crouches behind Errigal to shelter from expected backlash*

I will not take the bait from his insulting thread.That was the reason I left another forum. I will finally again say that I have no problem with the the Galvin suspension but if the Sunday Game are the arbritrators then all assaulting incidents should be highlighted.Now I could be drawn into listing a number of cases which should be reviewed as that is the low form of argument and insult that the poster is seeking.RM there is no need to talk about the incident in detail it has been well covered by all media.

Real Kerry Fan wrote:

RMDrive wrote:Bocerty single-handedly has 2 Kerry men on the ropes here . Note the attempts to talk about anything other than the actual incident at hand. An admirable and expected defense but pretty groundless all the same.

*crouches behind Errigal to shelter from expected backlash*

I will not take the bait from his insulting thread.That was the reason I left another forum. I will finally again say that I have no problem with the the Galvin suspension but if the Sunday Game are the arbritrators then all assaulting incidents should be highlighted.Now I could be drawn into listing a number of cases which should be reviewed as that is the low form of argument and insult that the poster is seeking.RM there is no need to talk about the incident in detail it has been well covered by all media.

But do you want to dictate whether other people can talk about it or not? You might feel that all that can be said has been said, however others are entitled to talk about it till the cows come home if they want. You are trying to make out that Boc is being insulting and "low". I suggest he is merely highlighting a point that really annoys you.

I agree 100% with you about the video review. I know MMM and BE and all of Derry and Monaghan felt "picked on" last year as regards trial by TV. This year I know how they feel after Brick Molloy getting his suspension. Mickey Harte had it right - either review all video for incidents (all camera angles in full) or don't review any of it. The Sunday Game panalists cannot be the ones to decide who gets punished or who doesn't. BTW that is the GAA's fault, not the SG's. They are only doing their job.

The call here is a simple one, the GAA have to look at the way bans are dished out, as RMD said earlier and i have said last year, if players are going to be retrospectively banned then it MUST be across the board and not just in incidents where the media whip up a frenzy (like they do with PG most of the time).

What PG done wasn't the nicest thing in the world and had he done that to me i would have lamped the head of him, he deserves to be banned for what he done but then again if something like that happens in a match between say Carlow and Longford then that has to be given the same treatment!

We need a video analysis system that works on 3 fronts. 1) If the referee is deemed to have dealt with the situation on the pitch adequately then the video panel don't take any further action. 2)If the referee deals with the incident however he would like it reviewed by the panel then he reports the player and the panel deal accordingly (let the player off or ban him) and finally 3) if a player does something that a referee doesn't see but has been caught on camera then the panel step in and act accordingly.

That is very similar to the style of Aussie Rules only with Aussie Rules players get reported after the game with no action being taken during the game.

It's about time the GAA came up with systems that improved the running of the game and not with stupid rule changes weeks before the Championship begins!!

Finally, is there any need for posters on here to be mentioning the names of posters from other sites that are not on here?

I am very against trial by Sunday Game.

Jayo Cluxton wrote:I am very against trial by Sunday Game.

This man had a similar problem with Match of the Day, brilliant interview and great hair on Motty!!!

bald eagle wrote:

Finally, is there any need for posters on here to be mentioning the names of posters from other sites that are not on here?

This one obviously being aimed towards me - BE I'll answer you.

Is there any problem with it? We all know the individuals I named. They are anonymous internet posters. No harm done is there? Are we not doing more harm by naming and shaming individuals whom everyone knows (ie. Gaelic footballers, hurlers, management, referees etc.)??? Libel, slander, defamation and all that jazz.

3inarow08 wrote:
Is there any problem with it? We all know the individuals I named. They are anonymous internet posters. No harm done is there? Are we not doing more harm by naming and shaming individuals whom everyone knows (ie. Gaelic footballers, hurlers, management, referees etc.)??? Libel, slander, defamation and all that jazz.

Sounds like a very fair point to me.

3inarow08 wrote:And I love your little veiled threat at the end. I'll be sure not to warn Paul, just in case he loses any sleep over it.

veiled threat!!!!!! How do you work that one out????

[quote="Real Kerry Fan"][quote="bocerty"]

3inarow08 wrote:

Real Kerry Fan wrote:




bias my **** you should be on stage Triona - i call it as i see it - Gooch was doing a fair bit of 'diving' from what i seen of the game, it didnt take much to put him down, when Cavanagh was at the same craic a few years ago he was getting castigated by everyone, and Tom O' Sullivan was doing his share of fouling along with Griffin but you Kerry lads chose to ignore that and instead point out that Canty deserved red for the clash with Galvin - now thats bias. You are a more cynical side than you care to admit and yet we all get labelled with the puke football label when the truth is you guys are masters at it - Billy Morgan was right.

Had a certain Tyrone player done what Galvin done then i would guarantee it would have caused more controversy - had it even happened in an Ulster championship many of you would have had a field day but when its one of your own you are more selective in your criticism, thats bias Triona not the sh!te you accuse me off. I will have no problem criticising a Tyrone player if i feel they warrant it pity you cant do the same.

Look boc I have never attacked a county,club, player or fans but having read your post I note that you must have some almighty chip on both shoulders because I have never seen such vitriol against a county ,its players and supporters. I mentioned the Canty incident as an example of all serious incidents should be highlighted on the Sunday Game or none. I will not even bother to reply to rest of your rant.

perhaps you could point out my alleged vitriol against the county the players and supporters - my interpretation of an incident (which many others share incidently) involving 1 Kerry player hardly amounts to having an almighty chip on both shoulders. Were the player from any other county including my own i would be of the same opinion.

My work mate watched the game. He said Kerry will be mighty hard to beat.

I said galvin will be back for the semi and he asked if he was injured. I told him he was likely to be suspended and he said (sic) "What did he do?"

When I described the alleged incident he laughed and said "Don't be stupid".

Now I didn't see it, this man is totally neutral when it comes to GAA, so.........

I'd never have had Paul Galvin down as a gouger ...........

Strangely - the more vilified, highlighted and TV trialled he gets the more I like him.

Jayo Cluxton wrote:I'd never have had Paul Galvin down as a gouger ...........

Strangely - the more vilified, highlighted and TV trialled he gets the more I like him.

bocerty wrote:

Jayo Cluxton wrote:I'd never have had Paul Galvin down as a gouger ...........

Strangely - the more vilified, highlighted and TV trialled he gets the more I like him.

I have to agree with you there Boc. Can't understand it meself. But am becoming a bigger PG fan with every witch hunt I suppose.