McKenna Cup 2012 Thread

[bald eagle]

Did any of our Ulster posters get to any of the McKenna Cup games at the weekend? I've added the tables after week 1 but not sure if they will upload or not!



The only real shock of the round was Donegal losing to the Poly, wouldn't call Fermanaghs win over Antrim a shock result as we all know Fermanagh have underperformed in the last few years and while not considered one of the "big boys" they certainly are a decent middle of the road team.

Derry struggled past Cavan with the new goalie not impressing by all accounts, but i'd put that down to first game nerves while Brennan seemed more than happy with John McCamleys debut in the middle. I've heard that Paddy Bradley was due to come back this weekend but word from a few mates that know him is that he is trying to put if off for a week or two as there is still an element of fear in him that he may do it again.

[Thomas Clarke]

I've heard that Paddy Bradley was due to come back this weekend but word from a few mates that know him is that he is trying to put if off for a week or two as there is still an element of fear in him that he may do it again.

Corrected

[RMDrive]

Listened to the UUJ game on Highland and they seemed good value for their win. Their full forward (Hughes? I think) did very well on Neil McGee. Brick Molly the best for Donegal.

[bocerty]

Tyrone team fro Sundays game against Antrim
John Devine,
Aidan McCrory,
Conor Clarke,
Dermot Carlin,
Ronan McNamee,
Justin McMahon,
Stephen McNulty,
Aidan Cassidy,
Colm Cavanagh,
Peter Harte,
Peter Hughes,
Ronan McNabb,
Ciaran Gervin,
Niall McKenna,
Ronan O’Neill

[Thomas Clarke]

Tyrone team fro Sundays game against Antrim
John Devine,
Aidan McCrory,
Conor Clarke,
Dermot Carlin,
Ronan McNamee,
Justin McMahon,
Stephen McNulty,
Aidan Cassidy,
Colm Cavanagh,
Peter Harte,
Peter Hughes,
Ronan McNabb,
Ciaran Gervin,
Niall McKenna,
Ronan O’Neill

Interesting looking side, with only Harte, Colm Cavanagh and Justy McMahon established 1st 15 players from last year. Lot of players with promise on that side, and several will feature heavily for Tyrone in the next year or 2. Whether they will prove good enough to be successful is another matter.

[Thomas Clarke]

Derry manager John Brennan is insisting that Paddy Bradley should play against UUJ.

Bradley intimated earlier in the week that he might be better off delaying his intercounty return until the start of the national league for fear of a recurrence of his cruciate ligament injury but his manager told RTE last night that he'd prefer if his talismanic attacker grasped the nettle against Jordanstown in Saturday evening's McKenna Cup clash:

"I'm insisting that Paddy plays a part in the game. He will not be starting but I want Paddy to partake for the simple reason that he needs the confidence.

"He needs to get out there and get a good tackle inflicted on him to restore his confidence."

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Looks like John Brennan agrees with my assessment of Paddy's inner fortitude in my first reply to this thread. Still, I wouldn't be pleased reading that if I was Bradley, and sounds like the long expected clash between these two is brewing.

[bald eagle]

Didn't get to see the game at all but there is an excellent analysis on SC1 sports website (like to it on the Global GAA Twitter feed opposite)

Good win for Derry, good to see Bradley being made play for the exact reasons that Brennan said, the longer you are out the harder it is to come back and for a player like Bradley (who a mate of mine refers to as "Ducks Foot" due to the nature of his bravery) this would definately be the case.

Any word from our Cavan and Donegal bretheren on their game? Would like to know both points of view on it.

[Jonsmith]

Good win for Cavan yesterday against Donegal. They were the better team v Derry last week and inexperience cost them the game. Gearoid McKiernan kicked 4 points from play from midfield where himself and Givney dominated as they did against Derry.
Barry Watters (still only 23, played Championship v Armagh in '08 and then didn't play football for a few years) has had 2 excellent games so far and Podge Reilly is doing well at center back. Niall Smith's pace is a real addition to the half forward line. The lads are all in great shape physically and will be wanting to peak for the League when it begins.

Negatives are obviously giving away 2 bad goals yesterday and kicking 14 wides for the second week running. We faced 2 very experimental sides with a team containing 8/9 of our Championship side. But nonetheless a win is a win and the players seem to be happy with how things are going. They were in the gym at 6 this morning so they're very putting in great effort.

[Parouisa]

But nonetheless a win is a win and the players seem to be happy with how things are going. They were in the gym at 6 this morning .................

........ having left the resident's bar in the hotel at 5.55am .......

[The Puke]

But nonetheless a win is a win and the players seem to be happy with how things are going. They were in the gym at 6 this morning .................

........ having left the resident's bar in the hotel at 5.55am .......

[Parouisa]

But nonetheless a win is a win and the players seem to be happy with how things are going. They were in the gym at 6 this morning .................

........ having left the resident's bar in the hotel at 5.55am .......

Oh .... it's the guy who stalks me around these boards putting up

Constructive .....

Oooops - now I'm at it!

[Jonsmith]

But nonetheless a win is a win and the players seem to be happy with how things are going. They were in the gym at 6 this morning .................

........ having left the resident's bar in the hotel at 5.55am .......

[bocerty]

why would anyone need to be in the gym at 6am in the morning the day after a game. So Dublin win an All Ireland by training early in the morning and suddenly its the in thing.

All a load of bollox if you ask me, more time spent on the pitch with a ball in the hand is what most players need nowadays, its all gone mad with this strength and conditioning schite.

Theres a lot of coaches/managers out there getting a decent remuneration for their services who arent worth two balls of blue.

[Thomas Clarke]

Ah now Boc, in fairness to Val Andrews, he has probably tried and failed with that many different approaches during his career in his senior inter-county, 6am gym sessions are one final roll of the dice!

Val would be better off trying to build bridges with and motivate his most talented player, before Kieran McGeeney gets his paws on him.

[bocerty]

Ah now Boc, in fairness to Val Andrews, he has probably tried and failed with that many different approaches during his career in his senior inter-county, 6am gym sessions are one final roll of the dice!

Val would be better off trying to build bridges with and motivate his most talented player, before Kieran McGeeney gets his paws on him.

if he has tried and failed that many times TC its time to put your hands up and say this isnt for me let someone else at it. I know thats easier said than done in Cavan but they are going round and round in circles

[Thomas Clarke]

if he has tried and failed that many times TC its time to put your hands up and say this isnt for me let someone else at it. I know thats easier said than done in Cavan but they are going round and round in circles

I agree with you totally Boc. I don't rate Andrews at all, and 6am gym sessions aren't likely to change my opinion of him. His nomadic, success-starved journeys put him down there with his countyman Tommy Carr as being among the worst long-standing county managers of recent times.

Ironically, one of Carr's first actions when he managed Cavan was to effectively get rid of their then talisman, Dermot McCabe. Andrew's eschewing of Johnston echos worringly.

[Parouisa]

Bit harsh there lads. We don't really know why managers jettison players. We are not privy to dressing rooms or attitudes or the possible player politics that go on.

In fariness too are you likely to win much with the likes of Louth or Cavan - no offence intended? You are only as good as the players you have. There are at least 20 county managers that win nothing each year.

[Thomas Clarke]

Bit harsh there lads. We don't really know why managers jettison players. We are not privy to dressing rooms or attitudes or the possible player politics that go on.

In fariness too are you likely to win much with the likes of Louth or Cavan - no offence intended? You are only as good as the players you have. There are at least 20 county managers that win nothing each year.

Well, Cavan won the Ulster title the year before Andrews first took over. It was a young side that had also made an AI U21 final a couple of years earlier. Tommy Carr also had Dublin and Roscommon, but couldn't deliver even a provincial title with either, despite both those counties winning provincial titles within 12 months of his reign either starting or ending.

They are both very poor managers who are overly-obsessed with fitness and discipline, and what sets them apart from most other poor managers is that they seem to get chance after chance with various counties.

As for jettisoning Johnston, I don't doubt that Jelly is difficult to deal with, but he evidently wants to play inter-county football, and it is a shame that Andrews wasn't able to ensure he would do so with Cavan.

[Parouisa]

Tommy Carr was a miracle point away from beating Kerry in the QF in Thurles in 2001 - and it was not the greatest Dublin team ever. There are plenty of journeymen managers who are picked up by one county after another despite the lack of success. I wouldn't blame those lads at all. Their CVs are well known and they still land the jobs.

[Thomas Clarke]

Tommy Carr was a miracle point away from beating Kerry in the QF in Thurles in 2001 - and it was not the greatest Dublin team ever. There are plenty of journeymen managers who are picked up by one county after another despite the lack of success. I wouldn't blame those lads at all. Their CVs are well known and they still land the jobs.

There are few that do the rounds with as little success as those two Jayo. I can't actually think of any others who have had 3 stints and nothing (thus far, in Andrew's case) to show for them.

I don't blame Andrews or Carr either, as they obviously enjoy it, but I do question what either of them bring to a senior county side.