Ciaran Whelan as a pundit on the Sunday Game

Doesn't seem to have an awful lot positive or interesting to say. Admitted he should have got a red card today only he was retired from the game. Seems to represent everything that is wrong with the GAAs football pest match analysts, always being negative and forgetting that they were players themselves one time.

Didn't see it - what was he negative about cos if it was the game in Derry he was right beacuse there was very little positive out of that one.

Mossy the king as spoken you should listen

I didnt think he was too bad - better than Spillane pontificating year in year out.
He got a great dig in at them about always building Dublin up for the fall.
Believe it or not, he is actually quite shy so give him a few weeks before you make judgement.
Dara O'Cinnéide was muck for his first few weeks but he has improved a bit.
Maybe it would be better if they were going down the route of ex-players to have players of the same generation as pundits - why not have Dara O'Sé and Whelo? Brolly and Coyle?

On a side note, did anyone see the opening sequence of the afternoon broadcast of the Sunday Game? They did a spoof of the A Team (the GAA Team) Cyril Farrell saying "quit your jibber jabber fool" in his own inimitable way was one of the funniest things I have ever seen on tv!