Team of the Decade

did he take over mcconville in 2009? personally dont think he is off the same class a palyer as mcconville, mcdoneel, oneill, cavanagh, canavan. Just my personal opinion.

samin10 wrote:did he take over mcconville in 2009? personally dont think he is off the same class a palyer as mcconville, mcdoneel, oneill, cavanagh, canavan. Just my personal opinion.

Ya I heard he took over from McConville alright. Paddy Bradley it is so!

It's funny in some ways, not many other Ulster counties rate Paddy Bradley that highly outside of Derry.

i knew he was close to mcconvilles record last year, didnt realise he overtook it. i think bradley is good just not up with the best

samin10 wrote:i knew he was close to mcconvilles record last year, didnt realise he overtook it. i think bradley is good just not up with the best

That about sums him up all right Samin, good but just a level below many previously mentioned..

So the top two scorers of all time in the Ulster Championship and there's some posters that don't rate them that highly?!

I'm not saying they're top class by the way, just pointing it out.

3inarow08 wrote:So the top two scorers of all time in the Ulster Championship and there's some posters that don't rate them that highly?!

I'm not saying they're top class by the way, just pointing it out.

So we're all in agreement then so, lovely....it's

Dooher, McDonald, Galvin.
Cooper, Joyce and McDonnell.....or is it?

Boxtyeater wrote:

So we're all in agreement then so, lovely....it's

Dooher, McDonald, Galvin.
Cooper, Joyce and McDonnell.....or is it?

Hmmm.......no!

You couldn't have both Dooher and Galvin in the same team in my opinion. I'd go with Dooher, just cos he's been around more years. I'd stick in Geraghty or McDonnell. I'll go Geraghty.

And I'd have Canavan in there ahead of McDonnell in the corner.

To please Samin, McDonnell first sub, once McDonald goes down like a sack of spuds!

3inarow08 wrote:

Boxtyeater wrote:

So we're all in agreement then so, lovely....it's

Dooher, McDonald, Galvin.
Cooper, Joyce and McDonnell.....or is it?

Hmmm.......no!

You couldn't have both Dooher and Galvin in the same team in my opinion. I'd go with Dooher, just cos he's been around more years. I'd stick in Geraghty or McDonnell. I'll go Geraghty.

And I'd have Canavan in there ahead of McDonnell in the corner.

To please Samin, McDonnell first sub, once McDonald goes down like a sack of spuds!

You're becoming more aurguementative now than Bocerty..... So you're on:

Dooher, AN Other, Geraghty* (Loyal will be pleased)
Cooper, Joyce, Canavan...

Further up-date, clarification needed....Canavan peaked in the early to mid 00's so not for me...

Boxtyeater wrote:

You're becoming more aurguementative now than Bocerty..... So you're on:

Dooher, AN Other, Geraghty* (Loyal will be pleased)
Cooper, Joyce, Canavan...

Further up-date, clarification needed....Canavan peaked in the early to mid 00's so not for me...

Me and him are having a good debate over on another thread!

Well I'd start McDonald in CHF. And early to mid 00s is fine by me. Not many great corner forwards that have been around all decade. Gooch only started in 2004 sure (didn't he? I'm trying to think back on that - I'm doubting myself!).

first allstar for gooch was 2002

10. Dooher
11. Cavanagh
12. McConville
13. Gooch
14. Clarke
15. ONeill

thats the best forward line of the 00's in my opinion

samin10 wrote:10. Dooher
11. Cavanagh
12. McConville
13. Gooch
14. Clarke
15. ONeill

thats the best forward line of the 00's in my opinion

3 Tyrone, 2 Armagh and 1 Kerry - "the best forward line of the 00's" in your opinion???

I'm sick and tired of asking you, where's Conor Mortimor?

a strong case could be made for Galvin instead of Dooher, OSullivan instead of mcconville or Donaghy instead of Clarke. However its about preference, and thats mine.

Mortimor would not make the top 20 forwards for me, McDonald would not make the top 10 in my opinion.

samin10 wrote:a strong case could be made for Galvin instead of Dooher, OSullivan instead of mcconville or Donaghy instead of Clarke. However its about preference, and thats mine.

Mortimor would not make the top 20 forwards for me, McDonald would not make the top 10 in my opinion.

Ya I'm not arguing with your preference at all, however I definitely would have Joyce in there, no doubt about it.

And McDonald, in my opinion, would be in the top 10.

3inarow08 wrote:So the top two scorers of all time in the Ulster Championship and there's some posters that don't rate them that highly?!

I'm not saying they're top class by the way, just pointing it out.

Most of these posters would get nosebleeds if they got past Newry!!!.
Funny if any of the rest of us had picked on these two players and referred to them with the same affection as our northern brethren do we would be class as anti nordy f**kers.

Just my 5 cents worth.

Jim, are you on the right thread?

if you southerners got nosebleeds when you got to newry there would be rivers of blood running through the streets.

JimWexford wrote:

3inarow08 wrote:So the top two scorers of all time in the Ulster Championship and there's some posters that don't rate them that highly?!

I'm not saying they're top class by the way, just pointing it out.

Most of these posters would get nosebleeds if they got past Newry!!!.
Funny if any of the rest of us had picked on these two players and referred to them with the same affection as our northern brethren do we would be class as anti nordy f**kers.

Just my 5 cents worth.

wrong Jim - we up here in the occupied 6 counties already know you are all anti nordy f**kers

bocerty wrote:

JimWexford wrote:

3inarow08 wrote:So the top two scorers of all time in the Ulster Championship and there's some posters that don't rate them that highly?!

I'm not saying they're top class by the way, just pointing it out.

Most of these posters would get nosebleeds if they got past Newry!!!.
Funny if any of the rest of us had picked on these two players and referred to them with the same affection as our northern brethren do we would be class as anti nordy f**kers.

Just my 5 cents worth.

wrong Jim - we up here in the occupied 6 counties already know you are all anti nordy f**kers

And a happy new year to you to Boc still going to be as grumpy as ever!!!!!!!!

JimWexford wrote:

bocerty wrote:

JimWexford wrote:

3inarow08 wrote:So the top two scorers of all time in the Ulster Championship and there's some posters that don't rate them that highly?!

I'm not saying they're top class by the way, just pointing it out.

Most of these posters would get nosebleeds if they got past Newry!!!.
Funny if any of the rest of us had picked on these two players and referred to them with the same affection as our northern brethren do we would be class as anti nordy f**kers.

Just my 5 cents worth.

wrong Jim - we up here in the occupied 6 counties already know you are all anti nordy f**kers

And a happy new year to you to Boc still going to be as grumpy as ever!!!!!!!!

just sticking up for myself and my nordy brethern Jim - thats all

Any snow all the way up there

JimWexford wrote:Any snow all the way up there

I don't know about snow Jim but it all seems rather frosty and bitter cold.

yes jim loads of the stuff . theres more snow here than in kerry katona's bathroom !

redhandman wrote:yes jim loads of the stuff . theres more snow here than in kerry katona's bathroom !

no mention of the shoulders either

Dooher
Joyce
Galvin
Gooch
Clarke
O Neil

This is the best of the noughties as proven by science. Anyone who disagrees just hasn't a clue.

mossbags wrote:Dooher
Joyce
Galvin
Gooch
Clarke
O Neil

This is the best of the noughties as proven by science. Anyone who disagrees just hasn't a clue.

what science is that Mossy - Joyce wouldn't be anywhere near my team of the decade sorry